It looks like you are still using an browser that is no longer supported with security updates. Some features on this site may not work including the checkout. We strongly recommend that you either update your browser or use another one such as:

Google Chrome Microsoft Edge Firefox Safari
Contact us
About us
Loading...

Have you ever wondered why you couldn’t taste what was in the tasting note? Wine buyers’ and journalists’ expertise in finding nuances in wine can seem unattainable. Tasting notes aren’t just dreamed up but that doesn’t stop many appearing impenetrable.

The language of wine doesn’t necessarily instantly match everyone’s experiences. There is a kind of arms race in some circles to give the most obscure, flowery description of a wine. It all comes down to the writer’s ability to describe what they sense. In essence, a tasting note is an exercise in linguistic ability.

alcohol-party-glass-table

A recent study by Ilja Croijmans and Asifa Majid, Not All Flavor Expertise Is Equal: The Language of Wine and Coffee Experts (2016), tried to establish if professional wine and coffee buyers were better at describing what they could smell than normal people. People can distinguish nearly one trillion different smells so Croijmans, “had expected that because they [wine and coffee buyers] have so much experience, they would be correct more often when they smelled lemon or cinnamon.”

According to Croijmans, generally people who speak western languages struggle to describe aromas they’ve never encountered before. Could the secret to aroma expression lie in being a wine expert? Would wine experts be just as good at smelling coffee as wine? Could novices do as good a job as professionals?

Professional wine buyers would have a lot in common with professional coffee buyers. They both have to smell, taste and assess a product and have to be relied upon to detect subtle characteristics and aromas that ordinary people would miss. On the face of it, it seems fairly obvious. The process is very similar, right down to the slurping method of tasting. These experts decide on how the product will be sold based on what they can detect.

Croijamns and Majid found that wine and coffee expertise didn’t translate to the other profession. Unfortunately being a wine expert won’t open up another world of sensory aromas. However in their areas of expertise wine and coffee experts were much better at describing aromas than complete beginners. Something Charles Spence, an experimental psychologist at Oxford University agrees with, “research suggests that expertise is indeed very domain specific” he says.

So while you may be able to sense a vast number of different smells, your ability to describe them comes down to your previous experience at leastif you speak a western language. Jahai speakers, a language spoken by hunter-gatherers on the Malay peninsula, have been proven to be much better at naming smells than their English counterparts even if they’ve never encountered the smell before. Croijmans summarises it by saying “the ability to detect a wide range of aromas doesn’t really depend on age but on what odour receptors you have and what kind of cultural experiences you have with odours.”

So next time you’re reading a tasting note and wondering just how on earth you’re supposed to taste what’s written, the answer is simple. If you speak English, drink more wine.

In-Bond / Retail products

Your cart contains both retail and in-bond products, you cannot checkout with both.